Scholars Call for Accountability Behind Corporate Sponsorships
As Target faces public criticism, CAU students and faculty interrogate the line between meaningful HBCU investment and performative representation.

As Target celebrates awarding millions in scholarships to HBCU students through its partnership with the United Negro College Fund, the retail giant faces renewed scrutiny from the Black community over a controversial Halloween advertisement and DEI cutbacks—reigniting a national debate over corporate accountability and authentic representation.
The Target Scholars Program was established in partnership with the United Negro College Fund (UNCF) in 2021. Through this program, Target has awarded over $10 million to nearly 1,000 HBCU students. For the 2025-2026 academic year, the program was open to 6 HBCUs, including Clark Atlanta University. Mr. CAU took part in an ad campaign for the Target Scholar’s Program, which was released last month. In recent weeks, Target has also been under fire over a different advertisement; a children’s Halloween costume that critics say resembled blackface. This is not the first time this company has received backlash from the Black community. What does accountability and authentic representation actually look like with corporate partnerships?
Prof. Steve Carnegie, a marketing lecturer and program director for the Department of Marketing in the School of Business, gave his thoughts on the broader question. “As a professor at Clark Atlanta University, I value corporate investments in HBCU students. However, financial support does not exempt companies from accountability.”
Carnegie believes that “authentic representation requires acknowledging mistakes, listening to communities, and making meaningful changes to advertising practices.” Out of respect for our institution’s ongoing relationship with Target, Carnegie opted not to speak specifically about the Target Scholars ad. He did share that his overall perspective is that “companies should not simply seek to profit from African-American consumers. They should demonstrate a genuine commitment to the communities they serve.”
Clark Atlanta scholars were candid in their responses. “I think it is really important to recognize while we’re getting support, it’s not the right kind of support. Even though I understand that it’s definitely needed in some cases,” said Da’Karia King, a first-year Mass Media Arts student. When asked her thoughts on companies investing in Black students while also facing criticism over racial imagery, King shared, “For me personally, I feel like you can’t really support something if your ethics and views aren’t really in it. I think a lot of companies try to support Black students just to save face and it’s up to the university or the college or whatever to kind of step away from that support.”
Many Clark Atlanta students agreed with King and expressed disappointment in the university’s decision to partner with Target. Brooklyn Henderson, a freshman attending CAU, gave her thoughts on the Target Scholars ad and the message she feels it sends to viewers. “I’m not gonna lie, it felt like Target picked them to be like, ‘Black people-—get on our good side.’”
While Henderson does believe that seeing our student leaders in a national ad campaign is good and makes the school look good, she emphasized her belief that Target was not the right choice. “It should have been another company, like someone who actually supports us. It makes us look like a puppet. Like they can tell us, ‘oh put out an ad to get all the Black people on our side.’ And we did it. I don’t think we should have done that.”
In response to the ad, first-year scholar Amari Green shared, “It’s definitely important that CAU is represented at a higher level rather than just here on campus or in Atlanta. Do I think it should have been with Target? No. I think there’s definitely other brands that they could have gone to and other ways we could have approached it. But I think it’s good in theory.”
To ensure meaningful investment and true representation, institutions must look beyond financial opportunity and high-profile visibility. Lasting impact requires evaluating business partners and examining whether their core values align with the organization’s overarching mission. Ultimately, leaders must ask what standard they are setting—not only for their students, but for the world.












Very well written! & I agree, we have to let companies know that we can not be bought. They support our community publicly but behind the scenes we’re only pieces on their chess board.